Coming into
this week’s lecture, I wasn’t completely convinced that biotechnology could be
a valid form of artistic expression. Research in the field of genetics has lead
to numerous breakthroughs that have improved the quality of human life, but how
does art come into play?
One of the most important applications of biotechnology + art is it’s
ability to stimulate dialogue about biotechnological ethics in society. In the
case of Eduardo Kac’s GFP Bunny, where the artist created a genetically
modified rabbit that would glow when illuminated under blue light, one of the
main aspects of the project was concerned with “the lively social, cultural and
ethical debates provoked by this ‘man-made’ mutation” (Stracey, 2009). As long as the art has the purpose of raising these important
questions and sparking debates, it’s valid to use life as art in this way.
GFP animals including Kac's GFP Bunny (bottom left)
Source: <http://agapakis.com/hssp/splicing.html>
Paul Wolpe discusses advances in biotechnology and the importance of ethics and responsibility
Source: <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ovV7v2XYJAI>
One ethical standard for biotechnology in art should be that no
intentional harm should comes to living beings without purpose. According to
Art History Professor Frances Stracey, “bio-art is least successful, and most
contentious, when the science is reduced to mere aesthetic spectacle, and no
account is taken of the specific or paradigmatic differences that affect how
one discipline is mediated through another” (Stracey, 2009). I draw the ethical line at the creation of genetic hybrids for pets. Animals such as the Prolos Fira, Tigon and Doloin were
created for little more than having interesting looking pets or animals to
display. Hybrid animals tend to have shorter lifespans than normal species and
are more susceptible to cancers and other illnesses. The intentional creation
of animals susceptible to all these problems, only for the sake of spectacle, is not ethical artistic expression.
Genetic crossbreed animals: Prolos Fira (Lemur-Cat, left) and Doloin (Dog-Lion, right)
Source: <http://listverse.com/2008/04/01/top-10-bizarre-genetically-modified-organisms/>
Works Cited
Eun, Seo. "Genetically
Modified Organisms." Genetically
Modified Organism. Slideshare, 30 Aug. 2011. Web. 19 July 2014.
<http://www.slideshare.net/ArleneTeodosio/genetically-modified-organism-9062878>.
"Macroevolution:
Crossbreeds." Introductory Biology:
Ecology, Evolution, and Biodiversity. North Carolina State University. Web.
18 July 2014.
<http://www.ncsu.edu/project/bio181de/Black/macroevolution/macroev_news/cross02a.htm>.
Solon, Olivia.
"Bioart: The Ethics and Aesthetics of Using Living Tissue as a
Medium." Wired. Conde Nast
Digital, 28 July 2011. Web. 18 July 2014.
<http://www.wired.com/2011/07/bioart/>.
Stracey, Frances.
"Bio-art: The Ethics behind the Aesthetics." Nature Reviews Molecular Cell Biology 10.7 (2009): 496-500. Web.
Pusta, Dana. "Animal Transgenesis and its
Applications." Bulletin of University of Agricultural Sciences and
Veterinary Medicine Cluj-Napoca. Veterinary Medicine 67.1 (2010).
Hey Alex! I like how you mentioned the importance of facilitating dialogue among these subjects. I touched on that too and I feel like those ethical stipulations that arise out of these developments pave the way for the future research that takes place. I agree with your statement about how no intentional harm should come without purpose. That just seems like a crucial stipulation in today's society and should be taken more seriously with regards to how far this research and exploration goes.
ReplyDelete